So, you’re spending Christmas in New York? Lucky you. Even if you don’t have Christmas Day in New York, the holiday season is magical no matter when you visit. If your Christmas wish is to experience this winter wonderland over the holidays, read on to discover how New Yorkers really celebrate the most wonderful time of the year.
Sure, we all love the Union Square Holiday Market and our breath is taken away every year by the Rockefeller Centre tree, but it’s our local traditions that make it really special. So, for a Christmas in New York City like a local, these are the spots you need to visit, the holiday treats you should feast on and the adored traditions you should take part in.
Ice Skate in Bryant Park
No Christmas in New York itinerary would be complete without ice-skating at least once - some of us might be more Bambi on ice than dancing on ice, but it’s the holidays, so who cares? Most people do flock to the city’s most iconic ice rink, which is of course the one at Rockefeller Centre, but most New Yorkers would tell you to get your skates on at Bryant Park instead.
The ice-rink is just as big as at Rockefeller, but the line is a lot shorter and the park itself gets a beautiful holiday makeover too. If you only have 24 hours in New York this holidays, make sure skating here is on your list!
Browse Fifth Avenue
Without a doubt, the biggest holiday tradition in New York is to see the window displays on Fifth Avenue. Despite the freezing temperatures, the occasional flurries of snow and the crowds, nothing says Christmas in NY like going to marvel at the windows of the ‘big three’ - Saks, Macy’s and Bergdorf Goodman. Saks also puts on an incredible light show when their windows are unveiled each year.
As well as these legendary stores, and others along Fifth Avenue, many locals also do Madison Avenue. Don’t be put off thinking it’s a little more out of the way or that Madison is too imposing! The windows here are spectacular, and you can really see how much work goes in to designing them - design actually begins over a year in advance, so what you see this Christmas will have started to be dreamt up last December!
Stroll through a Christmas Market
Some people even plan their vacations around when the window displays open! It might seem crazy to go crazy for a window display, but it’s a steadfast NY tradition so you can’t miss it. There are also plenty of holiday markets which start popping up across the city after Thanksgiving.
Stay warm at the Grand Central Holiday Fair, and you’ll feel like you’re in a movie as you browse the stalls filled with Christmas gifts inside the historic station. There's also the Union Square Holiday Market which has much more of a downtown vibe, and Artists and Fleas at Chelsea Market if you like to keep things independent.
Be in awe of the Met Museum Christmas Tree
A real must-see is the Christmas Tree located in the Met Museum on Fifth Avenue. The towering, 20-foot tree is decorated with 18th-century Neapolitan angels and cherubs. It might sound over the top but it’s a beautiful place to come and explore, especially decked out so angelically for the holidays!
A true hidden gem, however, is Met Cloisters, the branch of the museum that’s dedicated to European medieval art and architecture, housed in old cloisters which were brought over from Europe and rebuilt on the banks of the Hudson. Lots of people don’t even know this gem exists, let alone that it hosts a number of holiday concerts each year!
Dine at Rolf's
When it comes to food, there are a couple of spots that are known by the locals to be the place to go when you want to get in the festive mood. Rolf’s was once strictly a local hidden spot, but word has gotten out in recent years. In a space the size of a NY studio apartment (so we’re talking small, as any New Yorker will know!), Rolf’s is a German restaurant where not a single inch of the walls and ceilings aren’t covered with decorations.
Sure, it’s more than kitsch but that’s why we love it! Serving traditional German foods and beers, it’s an annual tradition to come here at least once during the holidays to catch up with friends, feast on hearty winter dishes, and generally, just enjoy basking in the glow of ten thousand Christmas lights reflected in ten thousand baubles. Now the secret’s out, make sure you get there before the queue starts!
Dazzling lights at Dyker Heights
But as any New Yorker will tell you, the most extravagant (and I mean really, out-of-this-world extravagant) Christmas lights are found in Dyker Heights. Making the pilgrimage out to Brooklyn to see the lights is the city’s other big holiday tradition after seeing the window displays, and once you’ve been yourself you’ll understand why.
There are even organized tours that will take you out to the neighborhood on a bus and around the most lavishly decorated houses, or if you want to brave the cold and are happy to use the subway, then you can always go for this DIY option.
However, I would recommend a bus tour for this, you’ll enjoy it all the more. You’ll be speechless when you see how lavishly each house is decorated - the whole neighborhood practically glows with neighbors all trying to outdo each other’s lights!
Hey curious traveler, visiting New York soon? Hey curious traveler, visiting New York soon? At City Unscripted, we create personalized city experiences led by passionate locals who share New York’s stories in a way no guidebook can. Whether you’re seeking hidden gems or exploring iconic landmarks, your experience is flexible and designed just for you — without the rigid structure of a tour. Discover the culture, history, and character of New York with a host who adapts the journey to your interests, making every moment feel unique and unscripted.
Top private experiences in New York
We’ll pair you with the perfect host
There is no better way to see a city than with a friend who lives there. This is why we carefully match guests with their perfect host based on interested, personality and type of experience so they can discover a city beyond the tourist trail.
